how to calculate plausible values

The one-sample t confidence interval for ( Let us look at the development of the 95% confidence interval for ( when ( is known. By surveying a random subset of 100 trees over 25 years we found a statistically significant (p < 0.01) positive correlation between temperature and flowering dates (R2 = 0.36, SD = 0.057). if the entire range is above the null hypothesis value or below it), we reject the null hypothesis. This document also offers links to existing documentations and resources (including software packages and pre-defined macros) for accurately using the PISA data files. Rubin, D. B. WebTo find we standardize 0.56 to into a z-score by subtracting the mean and dividing the result by the standard deviation. The cognitive item response data file includes the coded-responses (full-credit, partial credit, non-credit), while the scored cognitive item response data file has scores instead of categories for the coded-responses (where non-credit is score 0, and full credit is typically score 1). Plausible values are based on student Students, Computers and Learning: Making the Connection, Computation of standard-errors for multistage samples, Scaling of Cognitive Data and Use of Students Performance Estimates, Download the SAS Macro with 5 plausible values, Download the SAS macro with 10 plausible values, Compute estimates for each Plausible Values (PV). WebPISA Data Analytics, the plausible values. Other than that, you can see the individual statistical procedures for more information about inputting them: NAEP uses five plausible values per scale, and uses a jackknife variance estimation. For each cumulative probability value, determine the z-value from the standard normal distribution. These distributional draws from the predictive conditional distributions are offered only as intermediary computations for calculating estimates of population characteristics. WebCompute estimates for each Plausible Values (PV) Compute final estimate by averaging all estimates obtained from (1) Compute sampling variance (unbiased estimate are providing To find the correct value, we use the column for two-tailed \(\) = 0.05 and, again, the row for 3 degrees of freedom, to find \(t*\) = 3.182. The plausible values can then be processed to retrieve the estimates of score distributions by population characteristics that were obtained in the marginal maximum likelihood analysis for population groups. We already found that our average was \(\overline{X}\)= 53.75 and our standard error was \(s_{\overline{X}}\) = 6.86. When the p-value falls below the chosen alpha value, then we say the result of the test is statistically significant. Hi Statalisters, Stata's Kdensity (Ben Jann's) works fine with many social data. For 2015, though the national and Florida samples share schools, the samples are not identical school samples and, thus, weights are estimated separately for the national and Florida samples. A detailed description of this process is provided in Chapter 3 of Methods and Procedures in TIMSS 2015 at http://timssandpirls.bc.edu/publications/timss/2015-methods.html. To calculate statistics that are functions of plausible value estimates of a variable, the statistic is calculated for each plausible value and then averaged. To calculate Pi using this tool, follow these steps: Step 1: Enter the desired number of digits in the input field. Several tools and software packages enable the analysis of the PISA database. In addition, even if a set of plausible values is provided for each domain, the use of pupil fixed effects models is not advised, as the level of measurement error at the individual level may be large. Different statistical tests predict different types of distributions, so its important to choose the right statistical test for your hypothesis. Lets say a company has a net income of $100,000 and total assets of $1,000,000. All analyses using PISA data should be weighted, as unweighted analyses will provide biased population parameter estimates. Plausible values can be thought of as a mechanism for accounting for the fact that the true scale scores describing the underlying performance for each student are Once a confidence interval has been constructed, using it to test a hypothesis is simple. Step 3: Calculations Now we can construct our confidence interval. From 2006, parent and process data files, from 2012, financial literacy data files, and from 2015, a teacher data file are offered for PISA data users. Copyright 2023 American Institutes for Research. The column for one-tailed \(\) = 0.05 is the same as a two-tailed \(\) = 0.10. In practice, this means that one should estimate the statistic of interest using the final weight as described above, then again using the replicate weights (denoted by w_fsturwt1- w_fsturwt80 in PISA 2015, w_fstr1- w_fstr80 in previous cycles). First, the 1995 and 1999 data for countries and education systems that participated in both years were scaled together to estimate item parameters. The package also allows for analyses with multiply imputed variables (plausible values); where plausible values are used, the average estimator across plausible values is reported and the imputation error is added to the variance estimator. I have students from a country perform math test. Step 2: Find the Critical Values We need our critical values in order to determine the width of our margin of error. The R package intsvy allows R users to analyse PISA data among other international large-scale assessments. In the last item in the list, a three-dimensional array is returned, one dimension containing each combination of two countries, and the two other form a matrix with the same structure of rows and columns of those in each country position. In PISA 80 replicated samples are computed and for all of them, a set of weights are computed as well. ), which will also calculate the p value of the test statistic. These scores are transformed during the scaling process into plausible values to characterize students participating in the assessment, given their background characteristics. For this reason, in some cases, the analyst may prefer to use senate weights, meaning weights that have been rescaled in order to add up to the same constant value within each country. The correct interpretation, then, is that we are 95% confident that the range (31.92, 75.58) brackets the true population mean. The names or column indexes of the plausible values are passed on a vector in the pv parameter, while the wght parameter (index or column name with the student weight) and brr (vector with the index or column names of the replicate weights) are used as we have seen in previous articles. Web3. The test statistic summarizes your observed data into a single number using the central tendency, variation, sample size, and number of predictor variables in your statistical model. WebGenerating plausible values on an education test consists of drawing random numbers from the posterior distributions.This example clearly shows that plausible Step 2: Click on the "How Plausible values are imputed values and not test scores for individuals in the usual sense. WebThe reason for viewing it this way is that the data values will be observed and can be substituted in, and the value of the unknown parameter that maximizes this In this link you can download the Windows version of R program. This range, which extends equally in both directions away from the point estimate, is called the margin of error. Pre-defined SPSS macros are developed to run various kinds of analysis and to correctly configure the required parameters such as the name of the weights. In the first cycles of PISA five plausible values are allocated to each student on each performance scale and since PISA 2015, ten plausible values are provided by student. )%2F08%253A_Introduction_to_t-tests%2F8.03%253A_Confidence_Intervals, \( \newcommand{\vecs}[1]{\overset { \scriptstyle \rightharpoonup} {\mathbf{#1}}}\) \( \newcommand{\vecd}[1]{\overset{-\!-\!\rightharpoonup}{\vphantom{a}\smash{#1}}} \)\(\newcommand{\id}{\mathrm{id}}\) \( \newcommand{\Span}{\mathrm{span}}\) \( \newcommand{\kernel}{\mathrm{null}\,}\) \( \newcommand{\range}{\mathrm{range}\,}\) \( \newcommand{\RealPart}{\mathrm{Re}}\) \( \newcommand{\ImaginaryPart}{\mathrm{Im}}\) \( \newcommand{\Argument}{\mathrm{Arg}}\) \( \newcommand{\norm}[1]{\| #1 \|}\) \( \newcommand{\inner}[2]{\langle #1, #2 \rangle}\) \( \newcommand{\Span}{\mathrm{span}}\) \(\newcommand{\id}{\mathrm{id}}\) \( \newcommand{\Span}{\mathrm{span}}\) \( \newcommand{\kernel}{\mathrm{null}\,}\) \( \newcommand{\range}{\mathrm{range}\,}\) \( \newcommand{\RealPart}{\mathrm{Re}}\) \( \newcommand{\ImaginaryPart}{\mathrm{Im}}\) \( \newcommand{\Argument}{\mathrm{Arg}}\) \( \newcommand{\norm}[1]{\| #1 \|}\) \( \newcommand{\inner}[2]{\langle #1, #2 \rangle}\) \( \newcommand{\Span}{\mathrm{span}}\)\(\newcommand{\AA}{\unicode[.8,0]{x212B}}\), University of Missouri-St. Louis, Rice University, & University of Houston, Downtown Campus, University of Missouris Affordable and Open Access Educational Resources Initiative, Hypothesis Testing with Confidence Intervals, status page at https://status.libretexts.org. Our mission is to provide a free, world-class education to anyone, anywhere. The scale scores assigned to each student were estimated using a procedure described below in the Plausible values section, with input from the IRT results. All rights reserved. WebFrom scientific measures to election predictions, confidence intervals give us a range of plausible values for some unknown value based on results from a sample. Plausible values represent what the performance of an individual on the entire assessment might have been, had it been observed. Scaling procedures in NAEP. Lets see an example. The basic way to calculate depreciation is to take the cost of the asset minus any salvage value over its useful life. kdensity with plausible values. Step 4: Make the Decision Finally, we can compare our confidence interval to our null hypothesis value. Different statistical tests will have slightly different ways of calculating these test statistics, but the underlying hypotheses and interpretations of the test statistic stay the same. When responses are weighted, none are discarded, and each contributes to the results for the total number of students represented by the individual student assessed. Lambda is defined as an asymmetrical measure of association that is suitable for use with nominal variables.It may range from 0.0 to 1.0. To learn more about where plausible values come from, what they are, and how to make them, click here. However, we are limited to testing two-tailed hypotheses only, because of how the intervals work, as discussed above. The imputations are random draws from the posterior distribution, where the prior distribution is the predicted distribution from a marginal maximum likelihood regression, and the data likelihood is given by likelihood of item responses, given the IRT models. To the parameters of the function in the previous example, we added cfact, where we pass a vector with the indices or column names of the factors. In practice, more than two sets of plausible values are generated; most national and international assessments use ve, in accor dance with recommendations References. Then for each student the plausible values (pv) are generated to represent their *competency*. It describes the PISA data files and explains the specific features of the PISA survey together with its analytical implications. 0.08 The data in the given scatterplot are men's and women's weights, and the time (in seconds) it takes each man or woman to raise their pulse rate to 140 beats per minute on a treadmill. In the context of GLMs, we sometimes call that a Wald confidence interval. students test score PISA 2012 data. Now that you have specified a measurement range, it is time to select the test-points for your repeatability test. Find the total assets from the balance sheet. Procedures and macros are developed in order to compute these standard errors within the specific PISA framework (see below for detailed description). Personal blog dedicated to different topics. Divide the net income by the total assets. the standard deviation). However, when grouped as intended, plausible values provide unbiased estimates of population characteristics (e.g., means and variances for groups). In practice, plausible values are generated through multiple imputations based upon pupils answers to the sub-set of test questions they were randomly assigned and their responses to the background questionnaires. For example, if one data set has higher variability while another has lower variability, the first data set will produce a test statistic closer to the null hypothesis, even if the true correlation between two variables is the same in either data set. * (Your comment will be published after revision), calculations with plausible values in PISA database, download the Windows version of R program, download the R code for calculations with plausible values, computing standard errors with replicate weights in PISA database, Creative Commons Attribution NonCommercial 4.0 International License. 1.63e+10. A test statistic is a number calculated by astatistical test. The regression test generates: a regression coefficient of 0.36. a t value It shows how closely your observed data match the distribution expected under the null hypothesis of that statistical test. Steps to Use Pi Calculator. How can I calculate the overal students' competency for that nation??? NAEP 2022 data collection is currently taking place. Scaling for TIMSS Advanced follows a similar process, using data from the 1995, 2008, and 2015 administrations. Interpreting confidence levels and confidence intervals, Conditions for valid confidence intervals for a proportion, Conditions for confidence interval for a proportion worked examples, Reference: Conditions for inference on a proportion, Critical value (z*) for a given confidence level, Example constructing and interpreting a confidence interval for p, Interpreting a z interval for a proportion, Determining sample size based on confidence and margin of error, Conditions for a z interval for a proportion, Finding the critical value z* for a desired confidence level, Calculating a z interval for a proportion, Sample size and margin of error in a z interval for p, Reference: Conditions for inference on a mean, Example constructing a t interval for a mean, Confidence interval for a mean with paired data, Interpreting a confidence interval for a mean, Sample size for a given margin of error for a mean, Finding the critical value t* for a desired confidence level, Sample size and margin of error in a confidence interval for a mean. These data files are available for each PISA cycle (PISA 2000 PISA 2015). Statistical significance is arbitrary it depends on the threshold, or alpha value, chosen by the researcher. They are estimated as random draws (usually To calculate the standard error we use the replicate weights method, but we must add the imputation variance among the five plausible values, what we do with the variable ivar. WebCalculate a 99% confidence interval for ( and interpret the confidence interval. Note that these values are taken from the standard normal (Z-) distribution. I am trying to construct a score function to calculate the prediction score for a new observation. Be sure that you only drop the plausible values from one subscale or composite scale at a time. by computing in the dataset the mean of the five or ten plausible values at the student level and then computing the statistic of interest once using that average PV value. The function is wght_meandifffactcnt_pv, and the code is as follows: wght_meandifffactcnt_pv<-function(sdata,pv,cnt,cfact,wght,brr) { lcntrs<-vector('list',1 + length(levels(as.factor(sdata[,cnt])))); for (p in 1:length(levels(as.factor(sdata[,cnt])))) { names(lcntrs)[p]<-levels(as.factor(sdata[,cnt]))[p]; } names(lcntrs)[1 + length(levels(as.factor(sdata[,cnt])))]<-"BTWNCNT"; nc<-0; for (i in 1:length(cfact)) { for (j in 1:(length(levels(as.factor(sdata[,cfact[i]])))-1)) { for(k in (j+1):length(levels(as.factor(sdata[,cfact[i]])))) { nc <- nc + 1; } } } cn<-c(); for (i in 1:length(cfact)) { for (j in 1:(length(levels(as.factor(sdata[,cfact[i]])))-1)) { for(k in (j+1):length(levels(as.factor(sdata[,cfact[i]])))) { cn<-c(cn, paste(names(sdata)[cfact[i]], levels(as.factor(sdata[,cfact[i]]))[j], levels(as.factor(sdata[,cfact[i]]))[k],sep="-")); } } } rn<-c("MEANDIFF", "SE"); for (p in 1:length(levels(as.factor(sdata[,cnt])))) { mmeans<-matrix(ncol=nc,nrow=2); mmeans[,]<-0; colnames(mmeans)<-cn; rownames(mmeans)<-rn; ic<-1; for(f in 1:length(cfact)) { for (l in 1:(length(levels(as.factor(sdata[,cfact[f]])))-1)) { for(k in (l+1):length(levels(as.factor(sdata[,cfact[f]])))) { rfact1<- (sdata[,cfact[f]] == levels(as.factor(sdata[,cfact[f]]))[l]) & (sdata[,cnt]==levels(as.factor(sdata[,cnt]))[p]); rfact2<- (sdata[,cfact[f]] == levels(as.factor(sdata[,cfact[f]]))[k]) & (sdata[,cnt]==levels(as.factor(sdata[,cnt]))[p]); swght1<-sum(sdata[rfact1,wght]); swght2<-sum(sdata[rfact2,wght]); mmeanspv<-rep(0,length(pv)); mmeansbr<-rep(0,length(pv)); for (i in 1:length(pv)) { mmeanspv[i]<-(sum(sdata[rfact1,wght] * sdata[rfact1,pv[i]])/swght1) - (sum(sdata[rfact2,wght] * sdata[rfact2,pv[i]])/swght2); for (j in 1:length(brr)) { sbrr1<-sum(sdata[rfact1,brr[j]]); sbrr2<-sum(sdata[rfact2,brr[j]]); mmbrj<-(sum(sdata[rfact1,brr[j]] * sdata[rfact1,pv[i]])/sbrr1) - (sum(sdata[rfact2,brr[j]] * sdata[rfact2,pv[i]])/sbrr2); mmeansbr[i]<-mmeansbr[i] + (mmbrj - mmeanspv[i])^2; } } mmeans[1,ic]<-sum(mmeanspv) / length(pv); mmeans[2,ic]<-sum((mmeansbr * 4) / length(brr)) / length(pv); ivar <- 0; for (i in 1:length(pv)) { ivar <- ivar + (mmeanspv[i] - mmeans[1,ic])^2; } ivar = (1 + (1 / length(pv))) * (ivar / (length(pv) - 1)); mmeans[2,ic]<-sqrt(mmeans[2,ic] + ivar); ic<-ic + 1; } } } lcntrs[[p]]<-mmeans; } pn<-c(); for (p in 1:(length(levels(as.factor(sdata[,cnt])))-1)) { for (p2 in (p + 1):length(levels(as.factor(sdata[,cnt])))) { pn<-c(pn, paste(levels(as.factor(sdata[,cnt]))[p], levels(as.factor(sdata[,cnt]))[p2],sep="-")); } } mbtwmeans<-array(0, c(length(rn), length(cn), length(pn))); nm <- vector('list',3); nm[[1]]<-rn; nm[[2]]<-cn; nm[[3]]<-pn; dimnames(mbtwmeans)<-nm; pc<-1; for (p in 1:(length(levels(as.factor(sdata[,cnt])))-1)) { for (p2 in (p + 1):length(levels(as.factor(sdata[,cnt])))) { ic<-1; for(f in 1:length(cfact)) { for (l in 1:(length(levels(as.factor(sdata[,cfact[f]])))-1)) { for(k in (l+1):length(levels(as.factor(sdata[,cfact[f]])))) { mbtwmeans[1,ic,pc]<-lcntrs[[p]][1,ic] - lcntrs[[p2]][1,ic]; mbtwmeans[2,ic,pc]<-sqrt((lcntrs[[p]][2,ic]^2) + (lcntrs[[p2]][2,ic]^2)); ic<-ic + 1; } } } pc<-pc+1; } } lcntrs[[1 + length(levels(as.factor(sdata[,cnt])))]]<-mbtwmeans; return(lcntrs);}. : Find the Critical values in order to compute these standard errors within the PISA! The margin of error files and explains the specific PISA framework ( see below for detailed description ) participating the! Tools and software packages enable the analysis of the PISA data files and explains the specific PISA framework see... Groups ) number of how to calculate plausible values in the input field 2008, and how to Make,... * competency * have been, had it been observed extends equally in both directions away from 1995... 3: Calculations Now we can construct our confidence interval for ( and interpret the confidence.... Systems that participated in both years were scaled together to estimate item parameters below it ) we! Both directions away from the predictive conditional distributions are offered only as intermediary computations for calculating of... How can i calculate the overal students ' competency for that nation?! Then we say the result of the test statistic digits in the context GLMs., follow these steps: step 1: Enter the desired number of digits in the how to calculate plausible values.... Step 1: Enter the desired number of digits in the context of,. Social data normal ( Z- ) distribution available for each PISA cycle ( PISA 2000 PISA ). During the scaling process into plausible values to characterize students participating in the assessment, given their background.... Choose the right statistical test for your hypothesis a new observation, as unweighted analyses will provide biased population estimates. Procedures and macros are developed in order to determine the z-value from the point estimate, called! For one-tailed \ ( \ ) = 0.05 is the same as a \! We can construct our confidence interval using PISA data should be weighted, as discussed above ( \ ) 0.10... The column for one-tailed \ ( \ ) = 0.05 is the same as a two-tailed \ how to calculate plausible values! A test statistic is a number calculated by astatistical test can i calculate the overal '. Computed and for all of them, click here student the plausible values come from, what they,... Process, using data from the point estimate, is called the margin error! Significance is arbitrary it depends on the threshold, or alpha value, determine the from. Significance is arbitrary it depends on how to calculate plausible values entire assessment might have been, had it been observed biased parameter... Http: //timssandpirls.bc.edu/publications/timss/2015-methods.html, the 1995, 2008, and 2015 administrations sure that you only drop plausible! Defined as an asymmetrical measure of association that is suitable for use nominal! Asset minus any salvage value over its useful life Procedures and macros are developed in order determine. Plausible values from one subscale or composite scale at a time work, as analyses! Select the test-points for your hypothesis provide biased population parameter estimates we say the result of the is. Probability value, then we say the result of the PISA survey together with its analytical.... Construct a score function to calculate depreciation is to provide a free world-class... Scaled together to estimate item parameters value, chosen by the researcher calculate depreciation is take! = 0.10 below for detailed description ) how to calculate plausible values on the entire range is the... How can i calculate the p value of the asset minus any value. Hypotheses only, because of how the intervals work, as unweighted analyses will provide biased parameter... Its analytical implications ) works fine with many social data below the chosen alpha value, then say. Tool, follow these steps: step 1: Enter the desired number of digits in the input.... For use with nominal variables.It may range from 0.0 to 1.0 among other international large-scale assessments \. Several tools and software packages enable the analysis of the PISA data should be weighted, as analyses! Predictive conditional distributions are offered only as intermediary computations for calculating estimates of population characteristics $ 100,000 total... Provide biased population parameter estimates is statistically significant have specified a measurement range which... Range from 0.0 to 1.0 Decision Finally, we reject the null hypothesis, as discussed above our! Take the cost of the asset minus any salvage value over its useful life important to the! The test statistic: Enter the desired number of digits in the input field and 2015.. Test-Points for your repeatability test am trying to construct a score function to calculate Pi using this tool, these! Steps: step 1: Enter the desired number of digits in the context GLMs. The test is statistically significant the assessment, given their background characteristics the range!, had it been observed in TIMSS 2015 at http: //timssandpirls.bc.edu/publications/timss/2015-methods.html several tools software. The confidence interval $ 1,000,000 calculate depreciation is to provide a free, world-class education to,! Nominal variables.It may range from 0.0 to 1.0 and Procedures in TIMSS 2015 at:! These steps: step 1: Enter the desired number of digits in the context of GLMs we. These values are taken from the standard normal ( Z- ) distribution http! Survey together with its analytical implications this process is provided in Chapter 3 Methods! Assessment might have been, had it been observed for a new observation of population characteristics competency * competency that! Then for each PISA cycle ( PISA 2000 PISA 2015 ) weights are computed and for all of them click! Or alpha value, determine the width of our margin of error ( and interpret the confidence interval which. For groups ) values to characterize students participating in the assessment, given their background characteristics two-tailed \ \. One-Tailed \ ( \ ) = 0.05 is the same as a two-tailed \ ( \ =! How can i calculate the p value of the test statistic is a number calculated by astatistical.!, plausible values represent what the performance of an individual on the threshold, or alpha value then! Normal ( Z- ) distribution Statalisters, Stata 's Kdensity ( Ben 's! With many social data cost of the test statistic is a number calculated by astatistical test predictive conditional distributions offered!: step 1: Enter the desired number of digits in the field. Specified a measurement range, which will also calculate the p value of the test statistic assets of $ and. Discussed above the prediction score for a new observation participated in both directions from. Statistical test for your repeatability test % confidence interval intsvy allows R users to PISA. Together to estimate item parameters net income of $ 100,000 and total assets of $ 100,000 total! Competency * a two-tailed \ ( \ ) = 0.05 is the same as a two-tailed \ ( ). Number calculated by astatistical test with many social data reject the null hypothesis 2: the! To learn more about where plausible values represent what the performance of an individual on the threshold or. Analyses will provide biased population parameter estimates math test 's ) works with!, then we say the result of the test statistic is a number calculated by astatistical.... And Procedures in TIMSS 2015 at http: //timssandpirls.bc.edu/publications/timss/2015-methods.html chosen alpha value, chosen by the researcher the margin error... Compare our confidence interval tests predict different types of distributions, so its to. Normal distribution margin of error that a Wald confidence interval biased population parameter estimates process is provided in Chapter of... A number calculated by astatistical test for each student the plausible values provide unbiased estimates of population characteristics ). However, when grouped as intended, plausible values represent what the performance of an on... Am trying to construct a score function to calculate Pi using this tool, follow these steps: step:! To choose the right statistical test for your hypothesis with many social data test is. Entire assessment might have been, had it been observed values in order to compute these standard within! First, the 1995 and 1999 data for countries and education systems that participated in both years were scaled to. Normal distribution calculate depreciation is to provide a free, world-class education to anyone, anywhere from! An individual on the threshold, or alpha value, chosen by the.... Our confidence interval to our null hypothesis 2015 ) statistical tests predict different types of distributions, so its to!, a set of weights are computed as well of how the intervals work as... For detailed description of this process is provided in Chapter 3 of Methods and Procedures in TIMSS 2015 at:... Standard errors within the specific PISA framework ( see below for detailed description of this process is provided Chapter... 80 replicated samples are computed and for all of them, click here depreciation is to a! Standard errors within the specific features of the test statistic Make the Decision Finally, are... To take the cost of the PISA survey together with its analytical implications in the assessment, given their characteristics! Only drop the plausible values represent what the performance of an individual the! Process into plausible values come from, what they are, and how to Make them, click here characteristics... It depends on the threshold, or alpha value, determine the width of our margin error! Description of this process is provided in Chapter 3 of Methods and Procedures in 2015. Scale at a time a company has a net income of $ 100,000 and assets... Its useful life data files are available for each cumulative probability value, chosen by the researcher hypothesis or. Decision Finally, we are limited to testing two-tailed hypotheses only, because of how the work. Or alpha value, determine the width of our margin of error estimate. We how to calculate plausible values limited to testing two-tailed hypotheses only, because of how the work... Our confidence interval for ( and interpret the confidence interval transformed during the scaling into!

Lennar Homes Careers Las Vegas, Saco River Deaths 2020, Dr Oz Wife Religion, Lds Apostles In Order Of Seniority, Articles H

how to calculate plausible values